Dear Friends,

Last week, my office joined a coalition of states defending our ability to verify voter eligibility and maintain accurate voter rolls. We filed an amicus brief in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit in League of Women Voters v. Department of Homeland Security, supporting continued access to an improved federal citizenship verification program that Idaho is already using. This case is particularly important to Idaho because our state law requires us to use federal citizenship information to help maintain accurate voter registration records.

Both federal and Idaho law require citizenship to vote in federal and state elections, respectively. But establishing a requirement in law is only part of the equation. Election officials must also have a reliable way to verify that requirement.

For years, the federal government has made a program available to states called the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements, or SAVE. The program allows state officials to check an individual’s citizenship status against federal records. Unfortunately, the original system had significant limitations. Because it relied on federal immigration databases or DHS records, it lacked the ability to verify the citizenship of Americans born in the United States. The original system also required election officials to submit verification requests one individual query at a time.

Last year, the federal government updated the program to incorporate Social Security Administration records, expanding its ability to verify citizenship. The improvements also allowed states to submit multiple verification requests at once rather than processing them individually. These improvements made the system far more practical for states responsible for maintaining voter rolls containing millions, of records.

Idaho has already put these tools to work. In 2024, our Secretary of State’s Office reviewed Idaho’s voter rolls using federal citizenship verification resources and initially identified 745 registrations requiring further examination. After individual reviews, 34 cases were referred to the Idaho State Police for investigation, and 15 cases were subsequently referred to the U.S. Department of Justice for potential prosecution.

The distinction between those numbers is important. When the system cannot confirm someone’s citizenship, it means additional information is needed. Idaho’s experience demonstrates the importance of both reliable verification tools and careful individual review.

In June, a federal district court invalidated the 2025 improvements to SAVE, concluding that they violated federal privacy and administrative laws. The federal government appealed. In September, the Supreme Court of the United States paused that ruling while the appeal proceeds, and states can once again use the improved system. Our coalition is asking the appellate court to reverse the decision in support of the federal government’s improved system.

Protecting personal privacy is an important responsibility that my office takes seriously as we track data breaches and pursue companies that illegally sell or misuse private data. Under the updated SAVE program, states provide identifying information they already possess and receive a response indicating whether citizenship can be confirmed or further information is needed. The federal government does not provide states with the underlying Social Security records or put that data at risk for exposure.

Our argument rests on a principle the Supreme Court of the United States has long recognized: the constitutional authority of states to establish voter eligibility has little value without the ability to enforce those requirements. A law without the ability to enforce it is just a hopeful suggestion.

Congress expressly authorized the sharing of citizenship information between government agencies and required federal authorities to respond to citizenship verification requests from states. Congress also requires states to maintain accurate voter registration records. Idaho has demonstrated how these verification tools can be used effectively alongside individual review to administer our elections according to the law.

Every citizen deserves confidence that their vote counts. We’ve all witnessed what happens when people lack confidence in election outcomes and the credibility of that system. States cannot be expected to fulfill their legal responsibilities while being denied access to the very tools Congress authorized to help them do so.

Best regards,